Profile of the Speaker



Text of the Lecture

Romain Bertrand

France

 

Islam and Politics in Europe and in Asia:

Some Comparative Reflections



Perceptions of and attitudes toward Political Islam are different in Europe and in Asia. However, policy makers and governments in the two regions are confronted with the same key questions. What place could be reserved for religion in general, and for Islam in particular, in modern political life? What are or should be the relationship between State and religion ? What are the key challenges posed by Political Islam? How does Political Islam manifest itself in Asia and Europe and what are the differences and similarities in the way Europe and Asia are dealing with these challenges?

 

The majority of countries in Europe are indeed "minority Muslim countries", with a small percentage of their national population professing Islam as a faith and/or a way of life. In Asia, there are a number of "majority Muslim countries", which include countries whose constitution is officially premised on Islamic tenets. In several Asian countries, there also exist Islamist groups and political parties that seek a bigger role for Islam in the State. Most of these groups and political parties are in fact legitimate and exist within the legal framework. They also accept the principle of peaceful competition to gain political power and do not wish to confront nor destroy the State, but only to "seize it" through democratic or constitutional means. But there also exist extremist groups that would employ illegal means to wrest control of the State.

The call to religious values and for the establishment of an Islamic State in Asia is still restricted at the level of national politics. Asia certainly does not define itself as a Muslim entity, which contrasts with some views in Europe that Europe put forward its "common Christian inheritance". Nevertheless, the ideological use of religion and use of religious language in public debate is common currency in parts of Southeast Asia, where it has become part of the forging of "oppositional" identities. This phenomenon is not, for the time being, part of the political landscape in Europe.

The lecture by Romain Bertrand was hosted by the Asia Europe Foundation in Singapore and the Ministry of Foreign Afafirs, Brunei.

 

 
Copyright © 2003. Asia-Europe Foundation